Rage against mediocrity

The current war in the charts for the Christmas number one spot has me conflicted. For those of you who don't know (in my last post I left out one American in particular and I don't want to do the same again) in the UK we have a show called X Factor, much the same as American Idol but with just enough format tweaks for it to justify its relabeling. Every year I watch it, for the same reasons that I watch American Idol, because not everything has to be cerebral, sometimes I like to watch dumb shit. During the show I pick the one contestant who seems to be marginally talented, and then they either win or lose and I never think of them again. It's just not my cup of tea, music wise, but as an entertainment show it's gloriously awful and entertaining to watch.
But then the show ends, and the winner releases their single, just in time to trample all over the competition for the Christmas number one. The X factor winner's single has been Christmas number one for the last five years, all but destroying what used to be an entertaining British pastime, namely talking down the pub with each other who was going to be Christmas number one. It used to be a big deal. I remember being a kid and suddenly the charts seemed quite important around Christmas.. But that's no longer the case.
Until this year. Sick of the situation, a groundswell movement has to try and get 'Killing In The Name' by Rage Against The Machine to be Christmas number one instead. A ridiculous idea, doomed to failure, except that with over half the week gone, Rage are beating the X factor single by about 40,000 copies. So there's a very real chance that this could happen.
But enough background, most of you will be going, 'yes Paul, we know this.' But anyway, my initial thoughts about this were pretty much against it. For one thing, this is mainly gonna benefit Sony, of whom one of the main people is...Simon Cowell. Both singles are on the same label. Second of all, there is something to be said for the idea that everyone buying the single are behaving with the same sheep-like mentality that the people buying the X factor single are exhibiting, especially given the song's 'Fuck you I won't do what you tell me' message. And so at first I dismissed it.
But then the other night I was sat on Twitter that all of a sudden it occurred to me that I was looking at it all wrong. I then considered the situation again.
- Do I love Rage? Yes, unreservedly, they are one of my favourite childhood bands, and they introduced me to both metal and hip hop.
- Would I like them to be number one at Christmas? Totally.
- Do I like the idea of Simon Cowell in a strop? Indeed I do.
- So why don't you buy the download then? I dunno, how much is it?
- 65p from play.com......
And so I made up my mind, and downloaded a song that I have previously bought three times on CD, once on single, and once on tape. And now I am hooked, scanning the news hourly for fresh sales figures. But now, as if to confirm that I made the right decision, Rage appeared on Radio 5 live at 8.50 this morning. So, just as people were pulling into work, they were greeted with this:
Now I should point out this is decidedly NSFW. But the fact that Rage are back, playing together, and getting to do that on Radio 5 with Nicky Campbell (a horrible little turd if ever there was one) is surely cause for celebration.
So what are you waiting for? Go buy the single!









December 17th, 2009 - 18:42
Good post. I started commenting but it ended up being a little too long so I chucked it over here: http://blog.maccarocks.com/2009/12/17/rage-against-the-ma-oh-wait/
December 17th, 2009 - 20:50
And here’s where I thought you were gonna say you were getting it for us all for Christmas…
December 17th, 2009 - 20:53
I love the fact they said they wouldn’t do that bit, but they did it anyway – and it took them ages to realise.
December 18th, 2009 - 14:17
I am thoroughly torn. On the one hand, I see where these people are coming from – X Factor is a big pile of awful and the acts are getting worse every year. A bit of competition is necessary and I’d love to see Simon Cowell pissed off and that stupid Elderberry boy cry.
I just don’t like the choice of song. Not that I don’t like the song, but it’s Christmas for God’s sake! (Or Santa, or whoever you worship. For me, it’s Santa). They could have chosen something a bit nice and perhaps even Christmassy. But no, some flipping metal child somewhere said ‘hur, hur, wouldn’t it be funny if RATM were number one at Christmas with the least christmassy song ever?’ and now it might be…
So, in conclusion; X Factor not being xmas number one =good. RATM being xmas number one = bad.
Maybe I’ll release a Christmas single.
December 19th, 2009 - 18:51
Ian – well at least you still left me a comment! Nice post, any readers who haven’t, go read.
Kerri – Given my current situation, I don’t think I could afford it!
Jennie – I don’t care, go buy it! Or go get the muppets Bo Rap instead. That is awesome.
December 20th, 2009 - 12:25
Another reason to support the Rage cause, from what i’ve heard, all the royalties they recieve are going to Shelter. Charity or Lining Simon Cowell’s pockets? not too much of a tough choice.
Jennie – drownedinsound.com have been running a campaign to get a much more festive song in the christmas top 40 ‘Get behind me Santa’ by the rather excellent Sufjan Stevens. Worth checking out!